Low ridership, lack of funds leads to Southern Ontario Transit suspending service in Haldimand

HALDIMAND—Southern Ontario Transit’s (SOT) service in Haldimand has been suspended until further notice.

Rae Rivard, founder and owner of the company with his wife, Manisha, said the decision to suspend the service came down to two factors: low ridership and a lack of funding.

SOT operated in Haldimand for three consecutive months after several months of community engagement.

Rivard said during the community engagement phase, there was a lot of demand expressed for public transit (by which he meant residents were saying they were in favour of the idea of a bus in their community, and expressed an intention to use it at some point), but that didn’t appear to capture the actual need in the community (people who had no other option but to use public transit).

“There seems to be a mismatch between demand and need, and the reality is that there seems to be a lot of demand, but it’s not translating to people using the bus,” Rivard said. “The need did not match the sentiment in the community at this time.”

That difference is critical when it comes to making planning decisions, paying for fuel, etc.

Rivard said when the service was active, the main feedback SOT received was requests for expanded hours of operation; there were also requests for a wider service area.

“Put simply, people in Haldimand County wanted more of exactly what we were offering, and we would be happy to keep going with this if the right supports were offered,” Rivard said.

He had previously told The Press that while the enterprise was formally registered as an Ontario business corporation, “we run it as a not-for-profit” to keep it affordable for riders.

When even the worst-case scenarios for rider quotas and projections failed to materialize as expected for SOT, Rivard said it “just further reaffirms the fact that yeah, to a degree, public transportation – if it’s to be affordable and geared towards the public, and not for-profit – it requires a certain degree of funding and/or assistance.”

While he had had conversations with representatives from all levels of government about SOT and the service it was providing to Haldimand residents, Rivard said none of those conversations resulted in any type of predictable and ongoing funding.

That was disappointing for Rivard, because in his opinion, even if the transportation needs in the community weren’t enough to offset SOT’s operating costs, that doesn’t mean those residents’ needs should be ignored.

Rivard remains staunchly in support of the concept of public transit as a whole, saying that a community “cannot claim to be an equitable place to live if any citizen is denied access to the services they have paid for, and for a good number of people, not having access to transportation is the main barrier to full participation in society.”

If any Haldimand residents do need access to public transit, he urged them to make their voices heard by their elected representatives.

“Your needs will not be addressed if you don’t fight tooth and nail for the bare minimum. It should not be this way, but for now that is how politics works. Find allies in your community and support the ideas that make your world a better place; few others will do it for you.”

As for the future of SOT and its owners, Rivard noted, “The infrastructure is still in place to restart operations if the right conditions are met.”

Alternately, they might look at bringing their service to other areas.

“There’s a possibility that we could relocate the operation and pick up somewhere else,” he said. “Though Haldimand County was our first test environment, we hope it won’t be the last. … Our mission continues to be the addition of transit services as a permanent, critical, essential service in every community across Canada.”