HALDIMAND—Haldimand Mayor Shelley Ann Bentley and CAO Michael Di Lullo have different opinions on Motion 73, the private member’s motion submitted by MPP Bobbi Ann Brady that calls for the provincial government to eliminate the role of integrity commissioners (IC) in local government.
Brady asserted in an interview with The Press in the May 21 edition that the IC process is “rogue,” with “no clarity on what these reports or investigations should actually look like.”
She recommended replacing the third-party IC with current County staff leaders, such as the County CAO or clerk, when it comes to conducting code of conduct investigations involving Council.
Bentley agreed with Brady’s reasoning behind the motion.
“I agree with the elimination of the integrity commissioners. In Haldimand County, the cost of the IC currently stands at $85,791,” said the mayor. “Not to mention the personal costs for council members to hire municipal lawyers to investigate IC complaints.”
The $85,791.64 figure is the cumulative total Haldimand has spent on ICs between 2021-2026.
The annual cost for the IC has ballooned under the current term of Council. Former Haldimand IC Charles Harnick charged $3,771.38 for 2019-20 and just $1,582.00 in 2021-22. Current IC David Boghosian charged $49,793 for 2025-26, attributing approximately $34,000 of that expense to investigating the leaking of confidential County documents, ultimately finding Bentley guilty of four code of conduct violations and recommending a four-month pay deduction.
Bentley spoke of joining other councillors during a recent Rural Ontario Municipality Association (ROMA) conference to discuss the “weaponization of ICs. The IC was introduced in 2019 and I do not believe this has been successful in its mandate.”
She continued, “Our council is not the only one; chaos around the council table is happening right across Ontario and has gotten worse since the initiation of ICs. I have met several other councillor members who have had their pay suspended several times; one councillor had to pay her own way to attend ROMA and join our delegation to the housing minister for discussion of Bill 9.”
Bentley called the clerk and CAO “well compensated and very well versed in our Code of Conduct and Municipal Act. We also have the Ombudsmen, who is an independent body who makes sure you’ve been treated fairly by Ontario government and public services. They are free, independent, and impartial.”
The Press inquired with the County if the work currently conducted by the IC could realistically be completed by the CAO or clerk without generating additional costs; no answer was received prior to publication.
Bentley ultimately pushed for a return to politics in a pre-IC era.
“What has happened to common sense and a gentlemen’s agreement?” asked Bentley. “The road to hell is paved with good intentions.”
Di Lullo disagrees with the motion.
“This function should remain with an independent integrity commissioner, as independence is critical to ensuring impartial and credible investigations,” said Di Lullo. “The CAO’s role is to oversee the administration of municipal operations and staff, not to provide oversight of Council. Assigning investigative responsibilities involving Council members to staff could create role confusion, potential conflicts of interest, and undermine the perceived independence of the process.”
Haldimand-Norfolk PC Riding Association President Phil Hauser is also unimpressed with the motion.
“Quite frankly, it’s disturbing, but not surprising, that someone who avoids accountability through acts like parliamentary privilege would call for the removal of independent processes to keep politicians in check,” said Hauser, referencing Brady’s invocation of parliamentary privilege to deny participating in the IC investigation involving Bentley.
Vice President of the local Liberal Riding Association Peter Black weighed in as well.
Black, who served as a councillor in Norfolk from 2001 to 2018, argued for the need for consistency in municipal governance.
“Clearly everybody identifies there is a problem with integrity. It’s always a few, just as in society. Why do we have rules and regulations? Because some people have their own agendas,” said Black. “It needs to be independent.”
He argued against Brady’s assertion that staff could take over code of conduct investigations: “I don’t think that’s fair to staff…. We’re asking our employees to monitor us. I think they can give us advice; I think they can guide us, but I don’t think they’re the ones that should be dropping the hammer…. It just puts them in a super awkward position.”







